[Skip to Content]
Close

Coupons & Promotions

MOST WANTED ITEMS!! 

TOP QUALITY USED ITEMS WANTED:
SELL US ANY OF THE FOLLOWING ITEMS AND WE WILL GIVE YOU DOUBLE REWARDS POINTS ON FIVESTARS!
Current Model of Pro Line Golf Irons Sets
Current models of Pro Line Golf Drivers
Leather 12” to 14” Ball Gloves
Used Baseballs & Softballs
Quality Adult Softball Bats
Steel Weight Plates and Dumbbells
Olympic Weight Sets and Benches
Adult Hockey gear
Adult Hockey Skates
Quality Hockey Gloves and Elbow Pads All Sizes
Soccer Shoes size youth 1 and down
Soccer Shoes Size adult 6 and up
Treadmills, Elliptical, Stationary Bikes
 
 

Spring is here, and you know what that means...baseball and softball season!!
We have a great selection of new and used gloves, bats, catchers gear and all the accessories you'll need this season.

 

2018 Lacrosse gear is here!! 

We are your one stop shop for new and used lacrosse gear!! We carry gear from Under Armour, STX, Maverick and many more! 

 

We buy used baseball and softball gear! Outgrow last years equipment or simply looking to upgrade? Stop into Play It Again sports today to trade in and trade up! Walk out with cash, or create an even larger discount on new!! We buy every day of the week! 

Gear up for Golf!

Shop our great selection of new and used today!! Dont forget to bring in your gently used items to create an even larger discount on new! 

 

New Bat Rules for 2018! 

Let the experts at Play It Again Sports help you with all your questions around the new bat rules for 2018! Stop in today and chat with our experts! 

Rogue HG Bumper Plates

Rogue HG Bumper Plates

10# ($19.99)
25# ($29.99)
35# ($44.99)

Rogue HG Bumper Plate 45#

Rogue HG Bumper Plate 45#

45# ($54.99)

Football tackle dummies Football pop up bags

Fisher Pro-Down Pop-Up Football Tackle Dummies

Five Stars Reward Program

Join our Five Stars Loyalty Rewards program to earn points to receive $10,$20, or $40 off your next purchase! Click here to join and get the app for your phone.

Location Info

Our location map
4720 Cemetery Road
Hilliard, OH 43026
Look for stores with the Gold Standard Seal. They have been recognized for achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations and Customer Service.
This store accepts gift cards

Store Hours

Mon:10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tues:10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wed:10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thu:10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Fri:10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sat:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Sun:12:00 PM - 05:00 PM

Contact Store

614-529-9100
SIGN UP

for News and Promotions